3. Recommendations
Contents
Recommendation 1
That the Select Committee on Workforce Australia Employment Services consider in its Review how employment funds can be better used to facilitate access to specialist employment-related services and supports that meet the needs of diverse jobseekers to remove barriers to participation.
Recommendation 2
That the Review considers how access and equity principles can be embedded in all Workforce Australia services, not just specialised multicultural or refugee services.
Recommendation 3
That the Review considers how the Workforce Australia funding model can incentivise collaboration, flexibility and person-centred support to better enable employment services to meet the needs of jobseekers who have diverse experiences, aspirations and face different barriers to meaningful and sustainable employment.
Recommendation 4
That the Department of Employment and Workplace Relations ensures panel members with refugee specialist expertise are funded under Workforce Australia in all areas of high refugee settlement and that specialist providers are enabled to provide tailored support based on practices that have proven effective in supporting refugees to navigate settlement and employment transitions.
Recommendation 5
That eligibility to access Workforce Australia be extended to people seeking asylum who are living in the community in order to ensure that they can support themselves while their immigration status is resolved.
References
[1] RCOA. How many refugees have come to Australia?
[2] ALP National Platform 2021. https://alp.org.au/media/2594/2021-alp-national-platform-final-endorsed-platform.pdf
[3] Hugo (2011). A Significant Contribution: The Economic, Social and Civic Contributions of First and Second Generation Humanitarian Entrants; Deloite Access Economics (2019). Economic and social impact of increasing Australia’s humanitarian intake
[4] See, for example: RCOA (2010). What works: Employment strategies for refugee and humanitarian entrants
[5] Statistics are from 31 July 2022. 95,364 are people seeking protection who arrived on a valid visa and 11,813 arrived in Australia by boat and sought asylum before December 2014 (‘Legacy caseload’). See: Department of Home Affairs. Monthly Update: Onshore Protection (Subclass 866) Visa Processing – July 2022 and UMA Legacy Caseload: Report on Processing Status and Outcomes – July 2022
[6] Tahiri (2017). Not working: Experiences of refugees and migrants with jobactive. Fairfield Multicultural Interagency and Refugee Council of Australia.
[7] A series of individual and group consultations were held with refugee community members and service providers to inform this submission and RCOA’s submission to the Employment White Paper between October 2022 and February 2023. Quotes in this submission are taken from these consultations unless otherwise indicated. Quotes are not verbatim and have been paraphrased in places for clarity.
[8] Tahiri (2017). Not working: Experiences of refugees and migrants with jobactive. Fairfield Multicultural Interagency and Refugee Council of Australia
[9] See Refugee Council of Australia (2010). What works: Employment strategies for refugee and humanitarian entrants
[10] Case study is based on an interview with Dr Amin Miazai reported by ABC News. Census reveals migrants tend to be more highly educated. So why do they find it harder to land jobs?
[11] Case study has been drawn from Ziersch et al. (2022). Pathways to employment for social inclusion, health and wellbeing for women from refugee backgrounds, The University of Adelaide and Flinders University, pp. 49-51.
[12] Case study in RCOA and Australian Syrian Charity (2022). Addressing industry accreditation processes as barrier to employment of skilled refugees: A case study – Dentistry
[13] https://fecca.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/FECCA-Policy-Platform-2022.pdf
[14] See, for example, RCOA and Australian Syrian Charity (2022). Addressing industry accreditation processes as barrier to employment of skilled refugees: A case study – Dentistry
[15] Shergold, Benson and Piper (2019). Investing in refugees, investing in Australia. The findings of a Review into Integration, Employment and Settlement Outcomes for Refugees and Humanitarian Entrants in Australia, p.9
[16] Services on the national panel with expertise in both refugee support and employment services include: AMES Australia, Host International, Settlement Services International, The Salvation Army
[17] Settlement Data for all humanitarian visa holders by LGA who arrived from 1 June 2012 to 31 December 2021 (Department of Social Services)
[18] Statistics are from 31 January 2023. 98,930 are people seeking protection who arrived on a valid visa and 1,695 arrived in Australia by boat and sought asylum before December 2014 (‘Legacy caseload’) and have applications still on hand or under review. See: Department of Home Affairs. Monthly Update: Onshore Protection (Subclass 866) Visa Processing – January 2023 and UMA Legacy Caseload: Report on Processing Status and Outcomes – January 2023
[19] It takes an average of two years to process an initial onshore protection application and six years for a decision which is appealed to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. This means that a person can be waiting in Australia for many years before they receive a decision about their refugee claim. See Section 8, RCOA (2022). Rebuilding a principled and strategic refugee program: Response to the Australian Government Discussion Paper on the 2022-23 Humanitarian Program
[20] See: van Kooy and Ward (2018). An unnecessary penalty: Economic impacts of changes to the Status Resolution Support Services (SRSS); van Kooy and Randrianarasoa (2017). Giving asylum seekers a chance: Insights from a pilot employment program, Brotherhood of St Laurence; Fleay, Lumbus and Hartley (2016). ‘People Seeking Asylum in Australia and their Access to Employment: Just what do we know?’, Cosmopolitan Civil Societies Journal, Vol.8, No.2, 63-83; McMahon (2016). Working it Out: A rapid review of the evidence around employment among refugees and temporary protection visa holders in the Australian labour market, Settlement Services International
[21] van Kooy and Randrianarasoa (2017). Giving asylum seekers a chance: Insights from a pilot employment program, Brotherhood of St Laurence
[22] van Kooy and Ward (2018). An unnecessary penalty: Economic impacts of changes to the Status Resolution Support Services (SRSS)
[23] Dinshaw and Kneebone (2022). Labour in limbo: Bridging Visa E holders and modern slavery risk in Australia. Melbourne Social Equity Institute and Human Rights Law Centre.



