2. Employment services that work for jobseekers from diverse backgrounds
Contents
In responding to the questions posed by the review of ‘what would be the ideal?’ and ‘what needs to be done to get there?’ the following focuses on key principles that should underpin an employment service ecosystem that benefits jobseekers from all backgrounds, including newly arrived refugee and humanitarian entrants and people seeking asylum.
2.1 Diverse experiences require diverse strategies and employment services
Although the review asks for submissions to consider how to ‘create a system with less rather than more complexity’ it is important to note that jobseekers are as diverse as the Australian population itself. Refugee and humanitarian entrants, for example, are a significantly diverse population group. Many arrive with overseas qualifications and extensive prior work experience — they were business-owners, doctors, electricians, teachers, lawyers, managers and engineers. Others will have had limited opportunities to access training, education or work opportunities, or may have significant disruptions in their work histories due to experiences of persecution, conflict and displacement.
As the following case studies suggest, what is likely to work to support a refugee jobseeker into employment in Australia will vary significantly based on individual circumstances as well as broader place-based and structural factors.
It is hard to envisage a single employment service model that would suit Dr Niazai, Fatim and Carmen, although it is possible to identify the types of support that would assist each individual to pursue their career aspirations and overcome barriers to employment. It is not surprising that so many different employment-related programs have been established outside the Federally-funded employment services to meet the needs and circumstances of different groups of jobseekers.
There are lots of employment programs funded in different ways – through local government, state government, through regional development funding. It shows there are gaps in systems. There are lots of stopgap measures. (Employment service provider, regional Victoria)
While we understand the Review is considering how to create a system with less rather than more complexity, it is our view that service ecosystems can work provided there is adequate funding and incentives for collaboration (see also Section 2.3 of this submission). A model of jobseekers being eligible for funds to facilitate employment outcomes already exists within Workforce Australia, although there is potential to further expand how different kinds of employment-related support can be purchased or accessed with these funds. There are possible learnings that could be drawn from models such as the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) in this regard, which would enable local initiatives and specialist interventions to receive some funding through Federal employment services, and provide greater agency for jobseekers themselves to determine what support they require.
Funding within Workforce Australia to support employment service ecosystems that meet the needs of diverse jobseekers would address ongoing frustrations that existing programs and models that have proven effective, including programs funded by State governments and civil society, are often not recognised or sustainably funded. For many refugees and humanitarian entrants, these programs are the reason they have found work, yet it has been the Federally-funded employment service provider which has been financially rewarded. Some have been developed through the use of philanthropic funding or on the initiative of small, locally-based programs. Others are simply unfunded and undertaken by under-resourced but enterprising community associations and networks (see case study below). Were there stronger incentives to collaborate, coordinate and fund employment initiatives that meet diverse jobseeker needs, complex service ecosystems may well be what is needed to ensure people get the kinds of tailored support that helps them overcome barriers to employment.
2.2 Ensure access and equity principles underpin employment services
As per the Federation of Ethnic Communities’ Councils of Australia (FECCA) Policy Platform,[13] all people in Australia should have equitable access to government programs and services. This means that all services, not just specialised multicultural services, should ensure that barriers to participation for migrant and refugee communities are removed. This includes ensuring that all services have appropriate information in relevant community languages, are trained in the use of interpreters, hire staff that reflect the cultural diversity of the populations they serve, proactively engage culturally and linguistically diverse communities and organisations, and provide their services in ways to ensure full participation from multicultural communities.
All employment service providers should have staff who are competent and trained to work with refugee communities, and should ensure that their services are accessible to these communities. This may mean ensuring that meetings and appointments can be conducted with the use of an interpreter, opting for face-to-face appointments where possible, ensuring that clients fully understand their rights and obligations, and addressing other barriers to participation, such as disability, age, gender, parenting and other responsibilities.
These core requirements for access and equity should be embedded in all Workforce Australia services, not just specialised multicultural or refugee services. While specialist services are important to respond to the distinct needs of refugee communities, refugee and humanitarian entrants should not be excluded from participating in mainstream services either. This is especially important where specialist services may not be accessible (for example, due to location) or where there are not enough specialist staff to provide support.
Everyone should be able to go to a mainstream service and be served. Specialist services are important but not the only answer. I used to work in a specialist [multicultural] service; we only had one staff member working on employment issues on a part-time basis. If people from refugee backgrounds only had access to this, they would get sub-par service. Bigger services have greater capacity to do things. Perhaps a better way to do this is to locate employment services within local hubs, where you can work and collaborate. (Employment service provider, regional Victoria)
The growing use of digital services also hinders equitable access for multicultural communities, especially those who are newly arrived, who are elderly, who do not have digital literacy or do not have access to technology (for example, due to cost barriers). Many organisations and community groups have expressed concern with the growing trend to require digital access to services, especially when face-to-face or paper-based forms are not available. It is vital that alternative options to digital services are provided to all people to ensure fair and equitable access to government services.
2.3 Incentivise collaborative, flexible and person-centred support
Concerns have been raised by refugee community members and settlement service providers over many years about the incentive structure within employment service funding models that can push new arrivals into jobs that do not correlate to meaningful career outcomes or economic participation. Jobseekers can be pressured to accept entry level or low-skill jobs because employment services have been funded simply on getting a person into work, not on the fit or sustainability of job outcomes. For example, if a jobseeker has significant overseas experience and qualifications in a trade or profession, there may be a disincentive for providers to support job seekers to pursue qualifications recognition and industry-specific accreditation processes that can be a lengthy, complex and more expensive process to navigate.[14]
For employment services to effectively meet the needs of diverse refugee jobseekers, it is important that the overarching funding model incentivises collaboration and flexible, individualised support. Again, it should be assumed that jobseekers want to work, and that employment services are designed to be facilitators of outcomes that are person-centred.
Employment services have been driven by incentives, outcomes, KPIs. If they incentivise job outcomes, they will get a high turnover of jobseekers. They won’t have the patience to assist a refugee or migrant to have qualifications recognised. They want to get them in a warehouse job. The aspirations of jobseekers and support to find work commensurate to skill level is not incentivised in this model. (Employment and settlement service provider, Sydney)
In terms of what would incentivise and operationalise a collaborative, flexible and person-centred approach, suggestions include:
- Ensuring employment consultants have the necessary skills and time allocated to understand a jobseeker’s individual circumstances, aspirations, barriers to employment, and provide appropriate and supported referrals and tailored support. Many of the service providers and community members consulted for this submission spoke about extremely problematic employment consultant-jobseeker ratios within some services, the low pay rates and qualification requirements of employment consultants, and, correspondingly, the lack of time allocated to jobseekers to ensure an effective person-centred approach.
Employment consultants get thrown to the wolves. Most don’t have any training in social work, but they end up being incidental counsellors – and then there’s no support for them to debrief, to handle clients who have really complex issues, and to make supported referrals. They just don’t have the training; they don’t have cultural competency in many cases. The key selection criteria is basically that you have held a job in Australia! Employment consultant is such an under-valued role, compared to what it should be. Consultants get paid entry level wages for what is really a position that requires a high level of skill. (Former employment consultant, regional Victoria)
- Ensuring collaboration is incentivised within employment service funding models, recognising that many of the barriers to employment that jobseekers face require interventions that are best provided by specialists outside of employment services, including by settlement, legal, health, migration, domestic violence, housing and other social services. In some locations, collaboration across services may be achieved through co-location or pooled place-based funding. At the very least, collaboration should be incentivised through shifting the proportion of funding allocated to service fees and away from outcomes-based payments and by requiring employment services have well-developed referral systems in place.
Workforce Australia is a perfect conduit to work with people. Jobseekers are there because they have to be, but it could be done in a way that benefits the whole person if you remove some of the punitiveness. To do this, the model would need to view unemployed people in a new way. It is a minor percentage who don’t want to work; most people genuinely want to work. It would be good if there were incentives to provide a broadness of service, to consult more fully and support coordination with other services. If your job is to address the barriers to employment, you’d look at this differently. (Former employment consultant, regional Victoria)
I did outreach from a Job Network service where, during employment consultations, they would identify and refer refugees to me, so I would meet them for appointments. It worked really well. I would ask questions: How long have you been here? Are you with your family? What are you dealing with? There would be men who would break down, and they would tell me all they were dealing with. They were dealing with so much, but no one asked them these questions. Feedback from the employment service after this collaboration was that we got people to be work ready quicker, and outcomes were more sustainable. They were impressed. (Settlement service provider, NSW)
- Ensuring employment services are accountable for demonstrating progress of jobseekers towards meaningful and sustainable employment outcomes within variable timeframes. Suggestions from those consulted included ensuring that progress is measured with reference to a jobseeker’s individual aspirations, and that progress can include actively addressing barriers to employment and within variable timeframes. Furthermore, there should be opportunities for people who are under-employed (working in a job below their skill and qualification level, or with insufficient hours) to access employment service to support career alignment.
They would need to strike a balance in funding models between service fees and outcomes-based payments. The service fee is currently too small. It means services don’t want to support a person for a year or two years. There needs to be an incentive to support people over longer time periods. There could be higher payments for professional outcomes; or outcome payments for equivalent work. Aspirations and goals need to be recognised. (Employment and settlement service provider, Sydney)
Workforce Australia is bogged down in bureaucratic requirements. The bar was set so low with jobactive. For example, the number of clients per consultant was something like 200 and as impersonal as it gets. It’s got better since then; the points system is better because more things can be counted as an activity. It’s no longer just getting people to submit useless applications. (Former employment consultant, regional Victoria)
2.4 Make a targeted investment in refugee employment specialists
While ensuring access and equity principles are applied to all Workforce Australia funded services is imperative (see section 2.2 in this submission), in areas of high refugee settlement it makes sense to make a targeted investment in refugee employment specialists to ensure that common and distinct employment challenges and barriers faced by refugee and humanitarian entrants are addressed in ways that draw on the expertise and connections that refugee employment specialists have developed over many years. This was well-evidenced in a 2019 government review that argued that, to improve the economic participation of refugee and humanitarian entrants, the government should use specialist place-based employment services in areas of high refugee settlement to “work with refugees to develop and implement a personal plan based on their strengths and aspirations and labour market opportunities.”[15]
Services with expertise in both the provision of settlement and employment services can ensure support is tailored accordingly. For many refugees, critical elements will include assistance with familiarising themselves with Australian requirements for resumes and interviews, navigating training pathways and understanding Australian labour markets, and follow-up support within the workplace. Specialist services in areas of high settlement have greater capacity to draw on a bicultural and bilingual workforce, established and trusted relationships with employers, refugee communities and local service systems to facilitate referral, and expertise in delivering culturally competent services.
Settlement organisations will do a better job as employment specialists. It takes community service experience to deliver well. For refugees, while you are supporting employment transitions, you have to consider mental health, parenting issues, trauma – it’s all happening at the same time. The typical [non-specialist] employment service staff member, that expertise is not there. The whole support network is not there. With settlement service providers, we have these support networks and understanding. (Settlement service provider, NSW)
RCOA commends the establishment of specialist licenses within Workforce Australia that recognises the needs of those who may require more tailored support, including refugee and culturally and linguistically diverse jobseekers. However, to date, there are only two refugee specialist employment services that have received funding to stand up services in three of the 24 Workforce Australia regions, despite the existence of many organisations with considerable expertise and experience in delivering both settlement and employment services, including on the Workforce Australia Services national panel.[16] Furthermore, there are key refugee settlement locations in New South Wales (Liverpool, Bankstown), Queensland (Brisbane, Logan and Toowoomba) and Western Australia (Stirling) where neither CALD or refugee specialist services have coverage (see Table 1 in full report).
Looking beyond just the number and location of Workforce Australia refugee specialists, it is unclear whether the Workforce Australia funding model recognises the abovementioned expertise, skills and capacities of specialist providers and the need to work in ways that are tailored and cognisant of the intersection of settlement, employment and the refugee experience. If specialist providers are funded but the funding model is generalist in nature, it is questionable whether there is a targeted investment at all.
I don’t know what these specialists are funded to do – do they have different KPIs? Are the motivations and outcomes that they are reporting on any different? (Settlement service provider, NSW)
At a minimum, the criteria for refugee employment specialist providers should include expertise in refugee settlement, or strong demonstrated partnerships with existing organisations with expertise in refugee settlement. They should be required to report on their engagement with other key stakeholders including refugee and migrant communities, on their use of translation and interpretation services, and on the cultural competency of their staff.
2.5 Expand eligibility to Federal employment services for people seeking asylum
At the end of January 2023, there were 100,625 people living on temporary or even expired bridging visas in the Australian community who have applied for asylum and are either waiting for an initial decision, have applications under review, or have received a final refusal.[18] Some have work rights. None have eligibility to access Workforce Australia employment services. In the context of the lengthy delays in processing onshore protection applications which means people are living on bridging visas in the community for many years[19], it is imperative that people seeking asylum who are able to work are supported to do so.
There is substantial evidence to show that people seeking asylum in Australia typically face a range of complex barriers that prevent them from finding stable employment.[20] Many people seeking asylum have limited capacity to work as they do not have access to secure housing options and may be dealing with trauma and mental health issues as a result of their forced migration journeys. Employers may be hesitant to take on workers whose visa status is unclear or requires regular renewal. For those who are able to work, most have limited support or resources to seek employment while they wait for the resolution of their immigration status.
Services working with asylum seekers are also limited by available resources and capacities to provide the kind of tailored employment services that have proven effective when working with people seeking asylum.[21] In a 2018 survey of services working with asylum seekers, for example, only eight of the 24 organisations surveyed were providing employment-related services to their clients.[22] This study concluded that: ‘tailored employment programs for people seeking asylum do exist but, in the absence of federal resources, are dependent on investments made by state governments, philanthropic organisations, community donations and volunteers.’ It is our view that extending eligibility to Workforce Australia to people seeking asylum is a better investment by the Federal government than forcing people into destitution through reliance on charities or limited income through Status Resolution Support Services (SRSS), or than placing people on bridging visas at greater risk of worker exploitation and modern slavery, as has been detailed in a recent report from the Melbourne Social Equity Institute and Human Rights Law Centre.[23]



