Refugee Council of Australia
Whatworks_cover x

Submission to the review of the Workforce Australia employment services system

1. Employment services and refugee and humanitarian entrants

Contents

1.1 Refugee and humanitarian entrants in Australia

Successive Australian Governments have made a commitment to providing a lasting home to people fleeing conflict, violence and persecution through the Humanitarian Program, with an average annual intake of 14,000 refugee and humanitarian entrants since 1977-78.[1] In 2022-23, the Program is planned to grant permanent visas to 17,875 refugees. The Albanese Government aspires to increase the size of the Humanitarian Program to 27,000 places a year, with an additional 5,000 places for community sponsored refugees.[2]

While the objective of the Refugee and Humanitarian Program is to provide safety and a long-term solution to people in need of international protection, research has also shown the significant contribution that refugee and humanitarian entrants make to Australia’s economy and society, including in the areas of jobs and skills.[3]

1.2 Employment barriers

While there are clear long-term benefits of welcoming refugees to Australia, people who have been forcibly displaced face a range of challenges that impact their ability to find work. At a minimum, their careers have been disrupted and they face the challenge of accessing an unfamiliar labour market in a new country. Many face other challenges, such as physical and mental health issues arising from their persecution and displacement experience. These compound other disadvantages faced by people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds, such as the need to master English required for different jobs, racism and discrimination, lack of Australian work experience or networks, and difficulty in having overseas qualifications recognised.

Barriers and challenges faced by refugee and humanitarian entrants seeking employment in Australia are well evidenced.[4] These relate to:

  • Job-seeker characteristics: English levels; the need to upskill or retrain, particularly for those who have had limited opportunities to work and access education prior to resettlement; lack of Australian work experience and industry-related networks; health and trauma recovery; and understanding of and navigating the Australian labour market.
  • Labour market and other structural barriers: Recognition of qualifications and prior experience; industry accreditation or licensing processes; accessibility of recruitment processes; racism and discrimination; access to transport and childcare; and ineffective employment services.
  • Immigration and visa status: There are many people whose visa status presents significant challenges for accessing or sustaining employment, with employers hesitant to take on workers whose visa status is unclear or requires regular renewal. This includes over 100,000 people who have applied for protection and are either waiting for an initial decision, have applications under review, or have received a final refusal.[5] Most are on bridging visas that require regular renewal and are not eligible for Workforce Australia (see Section 2.5 of this submission).

As a result of these challenges, it can take time for refugee and humanitarian entrants to transition to work as they learn English, strive to have their qualifications and skills recognised, train or retrain, build their social networks, and learn how to navigate the Australian labour market and services. However, a starting assumption is that people want to work.

1.3 Refugee experiences of employment services

Employment services have the potential to play a crucial role in supporting people from refugee backgrounds to make a successful transition into the Australian labour market. Despite this, RCOA has consistently heard from refugee and humanitarian entrants over many years how employment services can create more rather than fewer barriers to securing meaningful and sustainable employment. In a 2017 report focused on the previous jobactive, RCOA and the Fairfield Multicultural Interagency compiled over 100 case studies that highlighted a range of problems related to the introduction of jobactive, including:[6]

  • The lack of specialised services;
  • Jobseekers being asked to choose between learning English and looking for work;
  • Difficulties with streaming and the Job Seeker Classification Instrument (JSCI);
  • Compliance measures and implications;
  • Limited support with resumes and interview skills;
  • Job Plans and lack of understanding of rights and responsibilities;
  • Under-use of interpreters and lack of translated materials by employment services;
  • Inappropriate Work for the Dole placements;
  • Over-reliance on, and lack of support for use of, technology to look for work; and
  • Service users being treated with disrespect.

While we understand that Workforce Australia replaced jobactive in 2022, community members consulted for this submission do not necessarily distinguish between previous and current employment service models.[7] For example, in consultations community members referred interchangeably to ‘jobactive’, ‘Job Services Australia’ and even ‘Job Network’ services, as problematic and unhelpful:

When someone new comes to Australia, I tell them: ‘If you want to get a job, don’t go to an employment service. Come and see me.’ I will take them to a farm that I know, I will introduce them to people, and they can find work easily there. I don’t know what the employment services are paid to do, but it’s better not to go to them if you want to find work.   (Refugee community member, regional NSW)

I found a job by applying directly. The employer asked me: ‘Do you have an employment service provider, because we can talk to them and they can support you with uniform and boots?’ So I told them I was with this agency, and they got connected with them. When I called the employer to see when I should start, they said the employment service had sent someone else and they left me aside.  (Refugee community member, Melbourne)

These employment services are not helpful. I was with one for two years, looking for a job. When I found work, it was by my own effort.   (Refugee community member, Melbourne)

We want to work. We have problems with things like transport. I have a family of seven and we only have one car. I can’t go to jobs unless I can get there by public transport. They [employment service] send us to work where there is no public transport.  (Refugee community member, outer metropolitan Melbourne)

Consistent in the critiques of employment services over time, refugee and humanitarian entrants describe employment services that are designed for jobseekers who have a good understanding of Australian employment systems and workplace culture and are fluent in English. They also note a lack of incentive for employment services to provide the kind of targeted individualised support that would equip newly arrived refugee and humanitarian entrants to access the Australian labour market, and particularly to find work that is commensurate with qualifications, skills and aspirations.

It is like a business. They even delayed people from getting a job because they do it like a business; for them to earn new money. They don’t spend any time with you.  (Refugee community member, Melbourne)

If I want to work selling blinds, the employment service will pay for my tools and help with transport. But if I want to work as a dentist where my qualifications, skills and interests are, there is no support to pay for or prepare for accreditation exams. They are pushing us to find full-time jobs, but if I do that, I will not have time to study and apply for exams. They are suffocating us.  (Refugee community member, Melbourne)

The funding model is a problem. Services are under pressure. And then you have the star ratings. These star ratings pushed services to churn out people quickly because jobs meant money. It was impossible to meet all three [measures used for star ratings] with this funding model: client satisfaction, job outcomes and running a viable service. You ended up just picking two. There was no incentive to support someone who wanted to spend 18 months or 2 years getting accredited in their profession, for example. They’d be like: ‘18 months to sit exams! Are you kidding?’  (Former employment consultant, regional Victoria)

The problematic link between Federally funded employment services and compliance measures has been raised in the past in relation to jobactive[8], but also more recently as an ongoing tension in the relationship between Workforce Australia services and jobseekers. As one employment service provider commented about their current state government funding:

Jobseekers come to our service because they want to. We have the carrot without the stick. People want to be here, so our opportunity to build relationships and address the barriers to employment is better to begin with.

Along similar lines, a multicultural service provider in regional Victoria said:

There are two Workforce Australia providers in our area that have employed bicultural workers. They are making the effort and trying. We also mutually support clients. But they are confined by their parameters. There is also a difficult dynamic between that person [the jobseeker] and the employment service, because they are seen as an authority rather than an advocate. They have a stick.

What the above suggests are systemic problems with how Federally funded employment services have been perceived by jobseekers and incentivised to provide more of a ‘tick-box’ service than one that is able to offer personalised and tailored support to assist newly arrived refugee and humanitarian entrants into meaningful and sustainable work. At the same time, there is substantial evidence of approaches that work in supporting refugee employment transitions and economic participation.[9] This evidence has been built over many years through the experiences of services that understand both employment and settlement transitions (see Refugee Careers Pathways Pilot case study following, as one example), including providers that have been funded through previous and current iterations of Federal employment services.

Key features of effective employment services include:

  • Individual case management and referral services, particularly specialist services that have expertise in delivering both settlement and employment support.
  • Mentoring programs with an employment focus.
  • Information and training on Australian work culture and systems.
  • Work experience programs.
  • Industry-related training targeting migrant and refugee communities.
  • Services providing career advice, planning and job search support.
  • Social enterprise and initiatives supporting small business development.
  • Services advocating and liaising directly with employers.
  • Services providing support with skills and qualification recognition, including bridging courses that lead to industry-recognised qualifications or licencing.
  • English language classes with an employment focus; and
  • Post-employment follow-up and support.

Case study: Refugee Career Pathways Pilot (CPP)

The Career Pathways Pilot (CPP) was a three-year pilot employability program funded by the Department of Social Services which ran from 2017 to 2019. It aimed to facilitate employment transitions for skilled and qualified refugees within five years of their arrival in Australia. Rather than seeking to secure immediate employment for refugees, the pilot focussed on helping participants to find work that matched their professional or trade skills and qualifications. Service providers with expertise in refugee support and/or employment services were funded to deliver the CPP. Within the model, Career Pathway Advisors provided case work and career advice including: developing individualised career pathway plans; providing financial support targeted at skills recognition and industry accreditation; and providing assistance following employment outcomes.

AMES Australia’s CPP program supported 361 refugees to use their qualifications in professions such as medicine, pharmacy, engineering and business/accounting. Two key elements of success for the CPP program were that it allowed Career Pathway Advisors to identify the participant’s skills and build employability early in their settlement journey and to provide personalised engagement and emotional support. In surveys and focus groups undertaken by AMES, participants reported that they had increased their confidence, acquired a positive outlook, and developed strong social networks early in their settlement journey as a result of this support.

An AMES follow-up survey of the participating cohort conducted in June 2021 found that this personalised engagement had a lasting impact by enabling participants to build resilient employability and slowly accrue high-quality employment outcomes. Overall, the sampled participants had increased their employment rate through the COVID-19 pandemic, indicating many participants had found work in resilient occupations.

Source: Ette, H (2021). Maximising refugee employability by building resilience: evidence from Australia

Be a champion for refugee rights

Join our mailing list and be the first to receive active resources. We need you to show Australia cares about refugees.

Search

  • Category

  • Topic