Government’s response to scrutiny
Contents
It is well established that independent oversight and scrutiny can identify some of the issues of concern in detention, provide safeguards against abuse and neglect, and give more visibility to vulnerable population. As mentioned in our 2020 report, both formal and informal oversight in Australia are limited. Australia’s detention system continues to operate under a cloud of secrecy with inadequate effective oversight and scrutiny.
As explained above, the restrictions related to COVID-19 pandemic has had major negative impacts on the informal oversight by friends and supporters who used to visit the facilities The only recent positive development in this area is that the Commonwealth Ombudsman, as the NPM for immigration detention, now publishes its reports. However, as mentioned, those reports are not regular and are currently published only once a year.
It should also be noted that some of the previous oversight measures have been abandoned altogether. For example, Immigration Health Advisory Group (IHAG) that was the only independent oversight body with medical expertise was disbanded in December 2013. The IHAG had representatives from professional health authorities and provided oversight and advice to the Government in relation to medical care in detention, including mental health care. In response to the disbanding of IHAG, the Australian Medical Association said in December 2013 that
the Government and the Department now have a major challenge in understanding and dealing with complex health conditions in difficult circumstances without the benefit of the expert advice of the highly qualified and respected IHAG members.
In recent years, the responses of the Australian Government to scrutiny by national and international bodies have been a cause for concern. It is alarming that in its response to the scrutiny by international bodies, the Australian Government often tries to paint a different and more positive picture of what is happening in our immigration detention facilities. For example, in its 2021 national report that it submitted to the Human Rights Council in advance of our third Universal Periodic Review, the Australian Government described the immigration detention of children as below:
Immigration detention of children is always a last resort and children are detained for the shortest practicable time. It is the Australian Government’s policy that children are not held in immigration detention centres. In the event that a child is detained, they are accommodated in alternative places of detention such as immigration housing precincts designed for families, or in the community under a residence determination. In some circumstances, including airport turnarounds or where there are criminal or security issues, children may transit through held immigration detention.
In stating that children ‘may transit through held immigration detention’ and in describing the places of detention where children are detained as ‘designed for families’, the Australian Government is significantly downplaying the harm its mandatory detention policies is causing children. The children who have been detained in closed detention facilities for over two years certainly did not ‘transit through held immigration detention’. The remote detention facilities that have held children (for example the APODs in Christmas Island) cannot possibly be described as ‘designed for families’.
Domestically, the responses of the Government to scrutiny by national monitoring bodies have been equally alarming. We assessed the reports that the Australian Human Rights Commission submitted to the Government since 2019 on systemic issues in immigration detention. We also assessed the responses of the Department of Home Affairs to those reports.
On average, the Department only agreed with around 20% of the recommendations in full. For example, the latest report published by the AHRC related to the management of COVID-19 risks in immigration detention. Out of 20 recommendations, the Department agreed with six recommendations in full, two recommendations in part, disagreed with five and noted seven recommendations.
In another example, in its response to the AHRC report about the use of force in immigration detention published in 2019, the Department agreed in full with three recommendations out of 24. It agreed with two recommendations in part, disagreed with six recommendations and noted 13.
The responses to the reports submitted by the Commonwealth Ombudsman under its role as the NPM for immigration detention facilities have been more favourable. The Government accepted the majority of the recommendations in full. For example, the latest report of the Ombudsman which related to the oversight of the immigration detention facilities from July 2020 to June 2021 made 17 recommendations. The Department of Home Affairs agreed with 12 in full, one in part and noted 4 recommendations.
However, most of the recommendations that were accepted have not been implemented. In its reports, the Commonwealth Ombudsman provides an assessment of the implementation of the recommendations over years. According to its latest report, the Ombudsman is monitoring the implementation of 33 recommendations. It reported that ten of those recommendations were implemented and the Ombudsman was satisfied that no further action was required. On the other hand, it raised concerns about the implementation status of ten other recommendations. They were related to major issues such as handling of complaints, alternative strategies to manage people’s behaviour, use of force (including use of mechanical restraints), freedom of movement within the facilities and use of the controlled movement model, and access to programs and activities.
Another example of unsatisfactory implementation of monitoring bodies’ recommendations relates to the recent review of mental healthcare in detention. In 2019, the Australian Human Rights Commission inspected the detention facilities along with independent medical consultants. Following the inspection, the AHRC expressed alarm about the mental health of the detention population and assessed that the “treatment practices appear inadequate to deal with this problem”.
The AHRC recommended that the Department of Home Affairs commission a comprehensive review of the mental health care provided to people in detention. In its response, the Department of Home Affairs stated that in early 2020, it commissioned a “holistic review of mental health services to detainees in the immigration detention network including processes set out in the Procedural Instruction (PI) such as Supportive Monitoring and Engagement”.
We have, however, significant concerns about this review. In March 2021, when the Department of Home Affairs was asked for a copy of the review through a Senate question on notice, it refused to provide it on the grounds that the review will be “used to inform a planned major procurement activity and could advantage some tenderers during this process, compromising probity”.
The Department’s response to other Senate questions on notice in May 2021 (see, eg, BE21-198; BE21-199, BE21-200) revealed further information about the review, including a limited scope and methodology. The contract was awarded to a recruitment agency, was only for two months, no detention facility was visited by the review panel “due to COVID-19”, and while some staff and stakeholders were consulted, only two detainees in one detention facility were interviewed. The recruitment agency that was awarded the contract recruited a clinical team which included “a Specialist Psychiatrist with a special interest in psychodynamic psychotherapy and personality disorders”. Such review did not represent a genuine effort to comprehensively review the mental health support provided to people in detention. The Department reported that it was not considering a follow up review.





