Refugee Council of Australia
Detention fence

Detention in Australia: Report to the Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture

More extensive and frequent use of APODs

According to the Department of Home Affairs, hotels, hospitals, aged-care facilities, and mental health inpatient facilities can be designated as APODs. In response to a Senate question on notice, the Department reported that from 1 January 2018 to 31 January 2021, 170 APODs were used in Australia at any time, with the highest number in Queensland. The Department reported that as at 31 January 2021, 56 APODs were classified as “hotel-type APODs”. Based on publicly available statistics, we know that as of 31 March 2022, 112 people were detained in various types of APODs.

Most of the APODs that are in use are not purpose-built. Our understanding is that only Broadmeadows Residential Precinct, an APOD adjacent to Melbourne Immigration Transit Accommodation is built for the detention purposes. The non-purpose-built APODs are meant to be used temporarily and to address a specific need; for example if a person in immigration detention needs to be hospitalised for a period of time, the hospital will be considered an APOD.

The problem is that the Australian Government no longer uses the APODs, especially the hotel-type APODs, as short-term measures. Instead, people have been detained there for a long time. Many people who had been transferred to Australia from Nauru and Papua New Guinea (PNG) for medical treatment spent over two years in those hotel APODs and only released throughout the first half of this year.

We can argue that the more frequent and longer use of APODs is in part attributable to the Government’s failure to release people during the pandemic. As more people entered the detention system and as fewer people were able to leave Australia due to issues arising from the COVID-19 pandemic, the detention network was unable to deal with the influx. The result was overcrowding in purpose-built facilities and more frequent use of non-purpose-built facilities that did not meet any of the detention standards.

Many of the detention monitoring agencies stated over the past two years that the hotel APODs had over-restrictive conditions (see eg Ombudsman, Australian Human Rights Commission) . They lacked facilities for exercise and recreation, did not provide appropriate access to outdoors, were overcrowded, and lacked privacy. People detained in those facilities repeatedly told us that they spend 23 hours a day inside, in rooms with sealed windows and with nothing to do. Such an environment undoubtedly contributed to the deterioration in physical and mental health of people in detention that many of the agencies working with this population observed.

Further, when the Australian Human Rights Commission assessed the management of COVID-19 risks in immigration detention, it noted with concern that in order to manage the risks of an outbreak, more restrictions had been placed on people detained at hotel APODs. For example, they were no longer taken to the closest detention facilities to access outdoors areas or to access services such as the IHMS medical clinic. The AHRC was seriously concerned about a number of people in those APODs who had not left the hotel floor on which they were detained for an extended period of time and remained in cramped rooms where they were not able to even open the windows.

While most people who were held for a long time in hotel APODs were eventually released, the fundamental problem of using makeshift and arbitrary measures to deal with overcrowding of detention facilities has not been addressed. When the conditions of the purpose-built detention facilities are so problematic, for example accessibility issues and prison-like environment, the facilities that are not built for detention purposes are highly unlikely to meet any of the detention standards. They should only be used for the shortest period of time and to meet a specific need (for example when hospitals and mental health facilities are used as APODs).

Be a champion for refugee rights

Join our mailing list and be the first to receive active resources. We need you to show Australia cares about refugees.

Search

  • Category

  • Topic