Length of detention(html)
Contents
One of the issues of significant concern in relation to immigration detention in Australia is the increasing length of detention. This is the direct result of lack of time limit associated with immigration detention.
The average length of detention in Australia has continued to rise since January 2020, standing at the staggering average length of 700 days, as of 31 March 2022 (the latest publicly available statistics). Last time we reported to the SPT, the average length of time in Australian immigration detention was 502 days (as at September 2019).
Over time, the percentage of people who have been detained for over two years has also increased. As of 31 March 2022, 35% of people in detention had been detained for more than 2 years, a significant increase from the last time we reported to the SPT, when that figure was 22%.
The Australian Government now provides further breakdown of the length of detention beyond two years. This is a welcome development. The current statistics break down the number of people who have been in detention between two and five years, by 6-monthly increments. The statistics, however, still group together all people who have been detained beyond five years.
As of 31 March 2022, 129 people were in that last category. Occasionally responses to Senate questions on notice provide further information about this group. For example, in December 2021, the Department of Home Affairs provided further breakdown about this group (see Figure 2) and revealed that there are people who have been in immigration detention for 14-15 years.
Increasing the likelihood of indefinite detention
In May 2021, the Australian Parliament passed the Migration Amendment (Clarifying International Obligations for Removal) Act 2021 without any public inquiry or formal consultation.
While on the face of it, the Act appears to be about preventing the return of people with well-founded fear of prosecution to places where they would be at risk of serious harm, in effect it increases the likelihood of indefinite detention. In cases where refugees cannot be removed from Australia to the country of origin due to a well-founded fear of persecution, the Act gives the Government the power to keep refugees in detention indefinitely, potentially for the rest of their lives.
The increase in average length of time in immigration detention can be partly explained by the two-year closure of Australian borders to manage COVID-19 pandemic. The border closure made it challenging to return people who were not refugees and on a removal pathway to their countries of origin.
However, the fact that more than 500 people are spending in excess of two years in closed detention can only be explained by the legal framework that provides for indefinite detention, as well as the lack of willingness of successive Australian Governments to acknowledge the harmful impacts of this law and meaningfully review the ongoing need to detain people.
In the 2018-19 Budget, the Government introduced new performance targets that indicated that the Department of Home Affairs aimed to either resolve the status of more than 85% of people detained for not having a valid visa, or to release them in the community within 90 days of being detained.
That target was clearly not met in that financial year, evident from the rising length of detention and lack of large-scale releases of people from detention, despite the claim in the subsequent year’s budget portfolio that the Department of Home Affairs is ‘achieving’ this target. The performance target was removed all together from future budget portfolios.





