Refugee Council of Australia
Detention fence

Detention in Australia: Report to the Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture

COVID-19 risks

Failure to release people from detention

At the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in March 2020, various health peak bodies and health experts in Australia wrote to the Federal Government and called for the release of those people from immigration detention who do not pose significant security or health risks. They highlighted lack of opportunities for adequate social distancing or self-isolation in immigration detention facilities. Australia’s Department of Health considered people in detention as one of the most at-risk groups to get the virus.

As time passed, more experts published advice and guidelines on mitigating the risk of infection in detention. There was unanimous agreement that as many people as possible needed to be released from detention, so those who could not be released could practice social distancing.

Australia’s Human Rights Commissioner called for the immediate release of people in detention who did not pose a significant security risk. The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists (RANZCP) called this issue “a public health issue of the first order” and urged the Australian Government to urgently release vulnerable people in detention. The RANZCP raised concerns about the transparency of the testing regime and medical oversight of the protection measures in place in detention facilities.

RCOA and many other organisations in the refugee sector and beyond highlighted this health advice and appealed to the Government to release as many people as possible from immigration detention. We initially did this quietly and by approaching a select number of decision makers in the Department of Home Affairs and the responsible Ministers.

We put forward practical solutions to achieve this, including reminding the Federal Government that it has at its disposal a range of community alternatives to detention. When those efforts failed, we called for consideration of health advice publicly.

The refugee sector continued to advocate on this issue throughout the peak of the pandemic and as security guards tested positive to COVID-19, as the case numbers in the community skyrocketed, as it became obvious that many of the metropolitan facilities were located in areas worst affected by COVID-19 (increasing the risk of outbreaks in detention due to the movement of staff in and out of facilities), and as more monitoring bodies published reports and recommendations about the management of COVID-19 risks in detention.

Despite all these efforts and continuous advocacy, the Australian Government continued to ignore the health and expert advice. While many countries in the world reduced their detention population size, according to the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC), the detention population in Australia increased by 12% in the first six months of COVID-19 pandemic. In fact, as illustrated in Figure 3, the detention population never went back to the pre-pandemic level.

We continued to receive reports from people in detention, member organisations, legal representatives and advocates, that people lived in crowded detention facilities and shared rooms and bathrooms with many others where it was impossible to practice social distancing.

In the earlier stages of the pandemic, people in detention reported lack of adequate sanitation equipment, failure to promptly replace hand sanitisers, and unavailability of Personal Protection Equipment. They also reported that lack of appropriate information and prompt messaging resulted in speculation and frustration.

In the absence of information and trust, people questioned every instance of isolation, movement, sudden absence of a staff member, and room searches, and interpreted them as signs that the detention management was dealing with a positive case of COVID-19. The situation was far worse in non-purpose-built Alternative Places of Detention (APOD), such as hotels. Those detention facilities accommodated one of the most vulnerable groups of people: those who had been medically transferred from offshore facilities to Australia for health care.

They had all spent over six years in Papua New Guinea or Nauru without access to adequate healthcare and many were dealing with serious and chronic illnesses, such as cancer and respiratory issues that put them at far greater risk of severe illness if they contracted COVID-19. However, people in those hotel APODs reported that they continued to share rooms often with four people and had very little access to fresh air. It should be noted that even before the start of the pandemic, both the Australian Human Rights Commission and the Commonwealth Ombudsman had raised serious concerns in relation to overcrowding and the overly restrictive environments of those APODs.

Failure to release people from immigration detention facilities and an increasing detention population resulted in the re-opening of Christmas Island’s North West Point Immigration Detention Centre in August 2020; a remote detention facility 2,600km from the Australian mainland with no adequate health facilities and far from lawyers and families.

Medical quarantine

The management of COVID-19 risks in immigration detention brought the use of medical quarantine into the spotlight. When the Australian Human Rights Commission examined the management of COVID-19 risks in immigration detention, it identified a number of serious issues with the use of medical quarantine. They were:

Use of high-care accommodation units for quarantine purposes

The AHRC raised concerns about this practice as high-care accommodation units are designed for behaviour management. As a result, their design is prison-like and highly restrictive with fixed furniture, limited natural light and limited access to outside. When people are placed in those units for medical quarantine, the conditions of their detention are similar to those who are placed there for behaviour management: they are mostly confined to their rooms and have very limited access to outside.

The AHRC considered the conditions in those units unsuitable for medical quarantine and raised particular concerns about the impacts on people with psychosocial disability. This is particularly an issue as there are concerns about the level of access to mental health support when people are placed in high-care accommodation.15 Use of medical quarantine after hospital discharge

The AHRC was concerned that people with significant physical or mental health conditions were being placed into 14-day quarantine, again in high-care accommodation units, after their discharge from hospital. The Commission stated that people returning from hospitals were likely to have significant vulnerabilities and their placement in such restrictive environment could cause serious harm.

14-day quarantine after offsite appointments

The AHRC stated that it was unclear why people in some detention facilities were being placed into 14-day operational quarantine after each offsite appointment. It was of concern that this practice happened in locations where the rates of community transmission of COVID-19 were low. The practice was also inconsistent with the treatment of security staff accompanying people in detention to the appointments as those staff were not required to be placed in quarantine.17 We also heard from member organisations that this measure resulted in a significant number of people declining medical care as they did not want to be in isolation for two weeks after each appointment.

The case study below clearly illustrates the impact of these measures.


Case study 1: Medical quarantine Mr A is a man with schizophrenia who has spent most of his time in Australia between prisons, immigration detention and compulsory hospital stays. Mr A’s psychosocial disability is well known to detention service providers because of the prolonged period he has spent in detention.

In the second half of 2020, Mr A displayed some symptoms that were similar to COVID-19 symptoms. He was coughing and had a runny nose. Mr A was told that he had to go to isolation in a high-care accommodation unit until he could get tested. No additional information was provided to him.

This news caused significant distress which was responded to heavy-handedly and without consideration of his psychosocial disability. He reported that when he said he did not want to be put in isolation, he was restrained by multiple Serco guards, placed in handcuffs and forcibly taken to the high-care accommodation unit.

The COVID-19 test was not immediately available, so he had to wait in isolation in the high-care accommodation unit for two days. Mr A called his lawyer in distress from isolation. Reportedly she struggled to ensure he was supported and safe as she was unable to speak to anyone from detention health to alert them to his precarious mental state at the time and was unable to speak to his allocated Home Affairs Case Manager.


The AHRC made two relevant recommendations: it asked the Australian Government to cease the use of high-care accommodation units for quarantine purposes and use less restrictive options. It also recommended that the Department of Home Affairs not place people with significant physical and/or mental health conditions, who were discharged from hospitals, in those units.

The Department of Home Affairs did not accept those recommendations.

Increased isolation

The main measures that the Australian Government employed to reduce the likelihood of outbreaks in detention facilities were imposing restrictions and keeping people isolated. Visits were cancelled, programs and activities significantly reduced, and people had far less freedom of movement within the facilities. While some of these measures were largely in line with the global practice, they were being imposed in an overcrowded setting with frequent movement of staff in and out which created an inherently risky environment for spreading COVID-19.

People in detention who spoke to us stated that they felt they were being put through significant restrictions mainly because the Government refused to accept the alternative, which was to reduce the detention population. They were also worried that none of those restrictive measures were going to keep the virus out for long given the staff frequented the facilities from areas with high rate of community transmission.

From 24 March 2020 to early December 2020, visits to all immigration detention facilities were suspended. The Australian Border Force that manages the detention network provided $20 phone cards each week to people in detention so they could maintain contact with their families and friends. We believe this blanket suspension of all in-person visits was not appropriate especially as in 2020, many Australian states and territories had managed to keep a very low rate of community transmission. This suspension resulted in prolonged separation of families and caused considerable distress.

It is of note that it was in that period of significant isolation that the Government tried to pass legislation to ban the use of mobile phones in immigration detention. While the legislation ultimately did not pass, the months-long debate that it generated created significant anxiety for people in detention and their supporters.

Mobile phones had been people’s main means of communication with their loved ones, lawyers and generally the outside world. They could be used at any time of the day, conveniently and from the relative safety of people’s rooms. The suspension of in-person visits only signified their importance. The re-introduction of such a Bill at a time of unprecedented isolation and uncertainty, in our opinion, was emblematic of the Australian Border Force approach to detention management: always through the prism of ‘risk management’ and with little regard for the wellbeing of people in detention.

In December 2020, visits resumed in a modified and restricted way, prioritising close family members and limiting the visits to one-to-one. Since then and as Australia dealt with multiple COVID-19 outbreaks, visits resumed and suspended again, with suspensions lasting much longer than any community restrictions. However, the suspensions have been more localised and contingent on the situation of the states in which each detention facility was located. Even today when almost all public health related restrictions in the community have been lifted, group visits have effectively not resumed. In most detention facilities, people in detention are limited to only one visitor per day, personal visits are prioritised, and the number of visits available per day remains limited. These restrictions make group visits very unlikely.

Finally, despite all these restrictions on, the Australian Border Force failed to prevent COVID- 19 outbreaks in immigration detention networks. Since mid 2021, there have been multiple outbreaks in large detention centres across Australia, including in Villawood Immigration Detention Centre in Sydney, Park Hotel APOD in Melbourne, and Melbourne Immigration Transit Accommodation.

Be a champion for refugee rights

Join our mailing list and be the first to receive active resources. We need you to show Australia cares about refugees.

Search

  • Category

  • Topic