Refugee Council of Australia
Detention fence

Detention in Australia: Report to the Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture

Consistent delays in release of detention statistics

In our previous report to the SPT, we raised a number of concerns regarding the immigration detention statistics released by the Australian Border Force. Most of those issues remain relevant today. While the Government now provides slightly more information about the APODs, for example it reports on the total population of APODs in each state, there is still no information about the number of APODs in use in each state and their individual population. The only further information occasionally provided is through the Department of Home Affairs responses to Senate questions on notice.

When the regional processing agreement in PNG ended on 31 December 2021, the statistics related to the more than 100 people who remained in PNG was removed. The Australian Government claimed that the Government of PNG has “assum[ed] full and independent management” of this population and therefore the “individuals remaining in PNG at 31 December 2021 are no longer part of the regional processing caseload”.

We disagree with this claim and believe that Australia remains responsible for the people it sent offshore more than nine years ago. There is currently no regular provision of information about this group, even their exact number. Lack of such reporting under the pretence that they are no longer part of the regional processing caseload is aimed to further reduce the scrutiny and solve a problem by pretending it no longer exists.

Another significant concern relates to the consistent delays in the release of detention statistics. While we mentioned in our 2020 report that the statistics were often published with delay, this issue has become far worse in the past two years. As of 3 August 2022, when this update is being drafted, the latest available statistics are from March 2022. This delay of 4 months has become the norm. RCOA has raised this issue several times with the Australian Border Force, highlighting the impact of timely release of the statistics on accountability. Unfortunately, it appears that the importance of timely release of the statistics is not equally felt by the authorities as this issue has been simply put down to lack of resources.

We ask the SPT to remind the Australian Government of the importance of timely release of the statistics. Considering the Commonwealth Ombudsman who is the National Preventive Mechanism (NPM) for immigration detention facilities only publishes its monitoring reports once a year, the statistics published by the Department of Home Affairs are the only source of information that provide an overview of the detention population and the detention network. Those statistics need to be released promptly to be meaningful as it is often of little use for the civil society to know how the detention network looked like four months ago.

Be a champion for refugee rights

Join our mailing list and be the first to receive active resources. We need you to show Australia cares about refugees.

Search

  • Category

  • Topic