Refugee Council of Australia
Two men huddling in yellow shelter

Eroding our identity as a generous nation: Community views on Australia’s treatment of people seeking asylum

Solutions and alternatives

Solutions and alternatives

The devastating and at times fatal consequences of Australia’s polices at an individual level; their enormous financial cost; the erosion of basic rule of law principles; the damage to Australia’s international reputation; the increasingly stark disconnect between Australia’s stance towards people seeking asylum and the on-the-ground realities faced by people seeking protection across the globe: all of these factors point to the fundamental unsustainability of Australia’s current asylum seeker policies. Reform is not merely an option, it is an inevitability. The human and financial costs of our current approach are simply too high to sustain.

Fortunately, the pathway to reform is clear. There are many practical measures that the Australian Government could take to restore humanity and fairness to Australia’s asylum seeker policies and address the shortcomings of our current policy approach. RCOA has developed the following ten-point plan outlining a range of policy measures and solutions which provide humane, constructive and effective alternatives to deterrence-based policies.

The reforms outlined below may not be easy to achieve but, with sufficient commitment and leadership, all are eminently achievable. There are alternatives to Australia’s current policies. It is now up to the Australian Government to decide whether to continue along its current course, knowing the likely costs and consequences, or to take a different approach which prioritises protection, fairness and human dignity

Encourage practical regional cooperation on refugee protection

Many political leaders and commentators have expressed fears that abolishing Australia’s current deterrence-based policy regime will lead to a resurgence of dangerous boat journeys to Australia and, consequently, an increase in loss of life at sea. RCOA believes, however, that these fears in fact reveal the fatal flaw in Australia’s deterrence-based approach: it cannot present a sustainable solution to dangerous sea journeys because it does nothing to address the root causes of this problem. Indeed, flight by sea is more accurately characterised as a symptom of a much broader and more serious problem, namely the limited (and diminishing) access to effective protection for people fleeing persecution across much of the world and particularly in the Asia-Pacific region.

So long as people fleeing persecution are unable to find a place of safety where they can enjoy the basic rights and entitlements which we should all be able to take for granted, they will continue to search for a means of escaping their predicament – including through undertaking dangerous sea journeys. In this context, deterrence can only ever be a stop-gap measure, not a sustainable solution. In fact, seeking to simply deter people seeking asylum from travelling to Australia by boat without providing viable alternative pathways to protection may trap them in highly precarious situations or force them to consider more dangerous methods of seeking protection, in turn placing them at even greater risk of exploitation by people smugglers and traffickers.

There is an urgent need for coordinated international action to ensure that people fleeing persecution are able to reach places of safety and receive the protection and assistance to which they are entitled. As a wealthy nation which has ratified the Refugee Convention and has a long history of providing protection and support to refugees, Australia is ideally placed to lead this action in the Asia-Pacific region. Unfortunately, the Australian Government’s actions over the past six years have eroded some of this leadership potential. The short-term, practical and attainable actions that are needed to drastically improve the lives of refugees in the Asia-Pacific rely on genuine leadership by governments in cooperation with civil society and local communities.

Recommendation 1

The Australian Government should, as a matter of urgency, develop a plan of action to enhance access to effective protection across the Asia-Pacific region, in line with the suggestions put forward in Section 5.1 of this report.

End Operation Sovereign Borders

Of all of the deterrence-based policy measures currently being implemented by the Australian Government, it is those which form part of Operation Sovereign Borders which create the most immediate risk of people seeking asylum being returned to danger. The practices of forcibly preventing people seeking asylum from entering Australian waters, screening claims at sea and casting them adrift in lifeboats all prioritise deterrence and enforcement at the expense of protection, failing to ensure safety of life at sea and placing people at high risk of being returned to situations where they could face persecution or other forms of serious harm.
The Government has repeatedly emphasised the strength of its resolve in implementing Operation Sovereign Borders and other deterrence-based policies. Should such resolve be applied to implementing a search-and-rescue response and building regional cooperation on refugee protection (in line with Recommendation 1), significant protection dividends could be achieved without placing people seeking asylum at such grave risk.

Recommendation 2

The Australian Government should:

  • End Operation Sovereign Borders and cease the interdiction of boats carrying people seeking asylum
  • End the practice of “enhanced screening” and ensure that all people seeking asylum have access to the full refugee status determination process, and
  • Replace Operation Sovereign Borders with a search-and-rescue response focused on safeguarding the rights of people seeking asylum.

Abolish offshore processing

Australia’s revived offshore processing regime has now been in operation for three years, during which time RCOA has conducted four national consultation processes.

The feedback on offshore processing we have received over this time period is alarming in its consistency. It is apparent that there have been few significant improvements in either the physical conditions of detention or efficiency of refugee status determination in Nauru and Papua New Guinea. Indeed, conditions appear to have deteriorated in some cases and the mental health impacts of prolonged indefinite detention under harsh conditions have become ever more pronounced.

Significant uncertainty remains regarding the ultimate fate of people who are found to be refugees after having their claims processed offshore. The two options nominated to date as solutions for these refugees (permanent settlement in Cambodia or Papua New Guinea) are still yet to be fully tested in practice and it is highly questionable whether they will prove to be effective, workable or sustainable.

There are a number of measures the Australian Government could implement to mitigate some of the harm caused by offshore processing. These include exploring alternatives to detention, expediting the processing of asylum claims, addressing shortcomings in physical conditions and enhancing independent oversight. So long as offshore processing is intended to act as a deterrent, however, RCOA is concerned that even these modest improvements will be difficult to achieve.

The threat of being sent to an offshore processing centre can only “work” as a deterrent if people seeking asylum believe that what they are seeking in Australia – safety, humane treatment, a fair hearing, an opportunity to rebuild their lives and a secure future – will not be available to them in Nauru and Papua New Guinea. In RCOA’s view, this creates a perverse incentive to maintain inhumane conditions. Efforts to limit detention, expedite processing of claims, improve physical conditions and provide durable solutions would in fact work against the policy’s intention, as offshore processing operates most effectively as a deterrent when detention is prolonged, processing is slow, physical conditions are harsh and the future is uncertain. In essence, the success of offshore processing depends on human suffering.

While RCOA would certainly welcome any efforts to alleviate the suffering of the people currently subject to offshore processing in Nauru and Papua New Guinea, we believe that objective of deterring people seeking asylum is irreconcilable with the objective of protecting people seeking asylum. As such, we see no viable way forward for offshore processing and strongly recommend that it be abolished entirely.

Recommendation 3

  • Offshore processing of asylum claims should be abolished and the detention centres in Nauru and Manus Island should be closed
  • All people currently subject to offshore processing should be returned to Australia for processing of their claims, and
  • All people who have been found to be refugees after having their claims processed offshore be returned to Australia and granted permanent Protection Visas.

Reform immigration detention

The Government’s commitment to releasing all children from closed immigration detention facilities is a welcome development. However, the fact that so many children were able to be lawfully held in immigration detention at all, let alone for such prolonged periods, highlights chronic and unresolved problems in Australia’s immigration detention system.

Time and again, under both Labor and Coalition Governments, we have seen people seeking asylum (including children) detained unnecessarily for prolonged and indefinite periods at an enormous human and financial cost. It is abundantly clear that we cannot rely on non-legislative policy measures and the goodwill of the government of the day to prevent prolonged, indefinite and unnecessary immigration detention. RCOA believes that it is imperative that legislative measures be introduced to ensure that no person in Australia will ever again experience the devastating consequences of prolonged indefinite detention.

Recommendation 4

The Australian Government should introduce legislation to:

  • Abolish mandatory immigration detention in favour of a discretionary system under which detention is applied as a last resort and only when strictly necessary
  • Restrict immigration detention to a maximum of 30 days without judicial review and six months overall
  • Establish a system of judicial review of immigration detention longer than 30 days, with subsequent reviews carried out at regular intervals if continued detention is deemed appropriate
  • Codify clear criteria for lawful detention and minimum standards of treatment for people subject to immigration detention, in line with UNHCR’s Detention Guidelines and
  • Prohibit the detention of children in closed immigration detention facilities, with community-based support arrangements to be used in place of closed detention.

Improve support for people seeking asylum in the community

Community-based support arrangements offer a humane and cost-effective alternative to closed immigration detention. In order to be successful, however, such arrangements must provide people seeking asylum with adequate support to ensure that they are able to live safely in the community and meet their basic needs without facing undue hardship. Not only is this support essential to upholding the human dignity people seeking asylum, it is also necessary to facilitate their participation in the status determination process. In addition, given that a significant number of people seeking asylum will eventually be recognised as refugees and remain in Australia on a long-term basis, providing adequate assistance at the beginning of their journey in Australia will help to ensure more positive settlement outcomes in the future.

The ongoing feedback received by RCOA indicating that many people seeking asylum in the community continue to face serious destitution, marginalisation, housing stress and deterioration in physical and mental health clearly illustrates that current community-based support arrangements do not allow for the provision of adequate support. We believe there is a need to substantially revise these arrangements to ensure that people seeking asylum are able to enjoy an adequate standard of living, successfully navigate life in Australia and participate in the Australian community.

Recommendation 5

  • Immediate action should be taken to enhance the capacity of the Department of Immigration and Border Protection to expeditiously renew expired Bridging Visas for people seeking asylum and ensure that no one becomes unlawful due to delays in visa renewals
  • Income support rates under the Status Resolution Support Service should be revised to a level which more accurately reflects the cost of living
  • Work rights should be granted expeditiously to people seeking asylum living in the community and targeted employment support services be made available to people with work rights
  • Vulnerable people who are not able to find employment should be given access to increased income support to reduce the risk of destitution and homelessness
  • Education and training opportunities should be expanded to ensure the young people have study options beyond high school
  • People seeking asylum should be granted access to the Adult Migrant English Program on the same basis as temporary and permanent humanitarian visa holders, and
  • Interpreting should be included as a “client service” for all support provided to people seeking asylum through the Status Resolution Support Services program and through torture and trauma counselling programs.

Reinstate a fair refugee status determination process

A robust refugee status determination process is essential to ensuring that people are not erroneously denied refugee status and returned to situations where their freedom, safety or lives could be under threat, as well as to ensuring public confidence in government decision-making. Recent changes to Australia’s refugee status determination process, however, are likely to achieve the opposite: they will create a far higher risk of inaccurate decision-making (in turn increasing the risk of people being returned to danger) and undermine the integrity of the assessment process.

RCOA believes that a quality refugee status determination system provides the most effective mechanism for making the necessary distinctions between credible and unfounded refugee claims, while also protecting people from being returned to danger. In our view, the most straightforward and effective means of resolving the status of people in the so-called “legacy caseload” is to restore a single statutory system of refugee status determination and cease imposing artificial delays on the processing of claims.

In light of the heightened risk of erroneous decision-making resulting from recent changes to the status determination system, RCOA also believes there is need for Australia to significantly improve its processes for monitoring the safety of failed people seeking asylum who are deported from Australia. Such monitoring would allow the Australian Government to assess whether its newly-introduced procedures and criteria for determining refugee status in fact allow for a thorough and accurate assessment of claims, as well as providing a safeguard for people seeking asylum who now have fewer protections against forced return to danger under Australian law.

Recommendation 6

The Australian Government should:

  • Restore a single statutory status determination process for all people seeking asylum, consisting of primary decision-making by the Department of Immigration, review by the Refugee Review Tribunal and access to opportunities for judicial review and Ministerial intervention
  • Restore access to the Immigration Advice and Application Assistance Scheme for all people seeking asylum at both the primary and review stages of decision-making
  • Repeal the Migration Amendment (Protection and Other Measures) Act 2015 and the Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Act 2014 to bring Australia’s refugee status determination process back in line with our Refugee Convention obligations and international guidelines on the assessment of refugee claims, and
  • Establish a system of periodic monitoring for failed people seeking asylum who are deported from Australia, to ensure that they are not subject to persecution or other forms of serious harm upon return.

End discrimination based on mode of arrival

One of the defining features of Australia’s current asylum seeker policies is the distinction they draw between different groups of people based on their mode of arrival, both in terms of the methods they use to reach Australia (boat or plane) and whether they hold valid travel and identity documents on arrival. In RCOA’s view, such distinctions – which have now become systemic – are entirely arbitrary. The mere fact that a person has arrived in Australia by boat or does not hold a valid visa bears no relationship to the validity of their protection claims and should therefore have no impact on the standard of protection they are able to access in Australia.

RCOA believes that it is unacceptable to arbitrarily deny access to certain entitlements as a means of deterring people from arriving by boat or without travel documents. Not only is this unfair, it is simply misguided. There is scant evidence to suggest that most of the discriminatory measures applied by Australia (such as denial of permanent residency and restrictions on family reunion opportunities) have any deterrent effect whatsoever; while there is considerable evidence to suggest that these measures have a significant negative impact on the capacity of the people affected to settle successfully, contribute to Australia and reach their potential.

Discriminatory measures also increase the complexity of Australia’s asylum seeker policies, resulting in parallel, duplicative systems, more complicated assessment processes and widespread confusion regarding eligibility for various services. This discrimination disadvantages many while benefiting no one and must be brought to an end.

Recommendation 7

RCOA recommends that the Australian Government repeal all legislative provisions and abolish all policies which discriminate against people seeking asylum refugees solely on the basis of their mode and date of arrival, including:

  • Exclusion from Australia’s migration zone
  • Requirement for mandatory immigration detention
  • Differentiated refugee status determination procedures
  • Denial of access to permanent residency and citizenship
  • Restrictions on access to family reunion opportunities, including differentiated processing priorities for family reunion applications
  • Restrictions on access to various support services, including legal advice and settlement services
  • Restrictions on overseas travel with right of return, and
  • Differentiated reporting requirements regarding change of address.

Improve protection for unaccompanied children

Issues relating to the protection and support of unaccompanied children have been among the most consistently-raised concerns through RCOA’s networks and community consultations. While the particular vulnerability of this group of young people is universally acknowledged, the current guardianship, care and support arrangements for unaccompanied children are seen to have significant shortcomings. In addition, the negative impacts of Australia’s current policies are often particularly acute for unaccompanied children; that is, the most vulnerable are among the worst affected. We believe that action is long overdue to end the harm inflicted by Australia’s policies on these vulnerable yet resilient young people and ensure that they receive adequate care and support.

Recommendation 8

The Australian Government should:

  • Amend the Immigration (Guardianship of Children) Act 1946 to remove the Minister for Immigration’s status as legal guardian for the unaccompanied children and appoint an alternative independent legal guardian
  • In consultation with State and Territory Governments, develop a national strategy for the care and support of unaccompanied children; and
c) Explore options for providing ongoing support to young people aged between 18 and 21 who arrived as unaccompanied children.

Improve protection for stateless people

With a global campaign to eradicate statelessness currently underway, it behoves Australia to give more serious consideration to the measures it can take to assist stateless people and reduce the incidence of statelessness. While most stateless people in Australia also have protection claims, there is currently no solution for those who are stateless yet not refugees. In order to appropriately protect the rights of stateless people, a robust statutory Statelessness Status Determination procedure is needed, with a substantive permanent visa available for those found to be stateless yet not refugees.

The situation of stateless children who are born in Australia also necessitates action. These children are entitled to Australian citizenship and failure to recognise this entitlement would place Australia in breach of both its own laws and its international obligations. Furthermore, the introduction of legislation which could have the impact of increasing statelessness rather than reducing it is hardly in keeping with our international obligations and global efforts to end statelessness entirely.

Recommendation 9

The Australian Government should:

  • Implement a statutory Statelessness Status Determination Procedure, based on recommendations from UNHCR and the draft model proposed in RCOA’s Stateless in Australia report
  • Establish a permanent substantive visa for stateless people who do not have other protection needs, granting the same level of access to support services and citizenship as permanent refugee and humanitarian visa holders;
c) Grant citizenship to stateless children born in Australia within a reasonable time, as required by the Australian Citizenship Act 2007, and
  • Amend the Australian Citizenship and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2014 to remove provisions which may increase the incidence of statelessness, as recommended in RCOA’s submission to the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs Committee inquiry into this legislation.

End the demonisation of people seeking asylum

The tenor of the public and political debate on refugee and asylum seeker issues has descended to a new low. Rather than driving measured discussion of Australia’s role in providing protection and settlement opportunities to people fleeing persecution and conflict, Australian political leaders have contributed to toxic attacks on vulnerable people seeking Australia’s protection. The Government’s decision to officially label people arriving by sea without a visa as “illegal maritime arrivals” is not only is inaccurate and specious but also has had the effect of making refugees who arrived in this manner feel unwelcome and dehumanised.

In spite of (or perhaps in response to) the toxic debate and lack of political leadership, there are myriad examples of everyday Australians resisting the branding of people seeking protection as “illegal” and seeking to counter the argument that the best thing Australia can do is turn people away. There is increased goodwill and a willingness to provide support people seeking asylum in Australia but there is little recognition by the Government of these efforts.
There is a desperate need for a measured dialogue and further education about the global and local issues of refugee displacement amongst the broader community.

Communication from Ministers and relevant Departments to people seeking asylum, refugee communities, organisations providing support and the general public must also be ramped up. The lack of regularly released clear and factual information has detrimental impacts not only on the people involved in the protection process but also the wider Australian public.

Recommendation 10

  • Australian Parliamentarians should demonstrate leadership in driving a calm, level-headed discussion on refugee and asylum seeker policy, with a focus on eradicating the myths and misinformation which permeates the public debate
  • In parallel (and in the absence of this political leadership), civil society members and other key decision-makers should seek to lead positive changes in public discourse
  • The Australian Government should, as a priority, cease using the word “illegal” to describe people seeking asylum who arrive by boat. This should apply both the departmental staff and Parliamentarians
  • The Department of Immigration and Border Protection, in consultation with civil society and refugee community members, should develop a comprehensive communications strategy to both clearly explain the protection process to people seeking asylumasylum see and dispel myths and misinformation about forced migration amongst the Australian public, and
  • Funding for human rights education should be reinstated.

Be a champion for refugee rights

Join our mailing list and be the first to receive active resources. We need you to show Australia cares about refugees.

Search

  • Category

  • Topic